It’s not necessary to live in the past, but in Chicago, it’s an interesting place for sure. While one is distracted by all the pleasant attractions of the present, the past is still very much here. The old neighborhoods have roots to other places and earlier times, and it sometimes makes for interesting juxtapositions.
The theatre in town these days is as remarkable as the live music, and all the art forms have had a pretty lively history in the city. It doesn’t take very long, however, before any discussion of history in Chicago turns toward a very infamous cow. The cow in question was named either Madeline or Gwendolyn, or maybe even Daisy, depending on the version of the story that one hears. This is the cow that kicked over the lantern, that in turn sparked the hay that had been recently stored for winter, on October 8, 1871.
In the ensuing tragedy that engulfed the city of Chicago in flames, 300 people perished, and 100,000 lost their homes. It’s a story so large, and so common in the North American vernacular, that there’s even a children’s song about it.
The connecting thread in all of the stories is one particular figure, a certain Mrs. O’Leary , who was milking the cow when it all went so terribly wrong. At least, that’s how the story goes. But visitors to Chicago these days, from the four star hotels Chicago offers, to the pubs where people gather and discuss the gossip of the day, might discover that the truth might be more complex than it seems.
It’s entirely possible that she was not, in fact, guilty at all, and possibly not even partially responsible. According to her own testimony, she was in bed when the fire broke out. There has also been a lurking suspicion about her neighbor, Daniel “Pegleg” Sullivan , whose testimony has lots of inconsistencies.
He claims that he was at her house, walked across the street, past his own house, turned and saw the fire, then ran back and saved a lot of the animals. The actions he describes are not only a little illogical, but also impossible. He simply didn’t have time. The firemen, likewise, have a complicated story that reveals a lot of dropped balls, and a number of opportunities not taken. This all suggests that she really might be just a scapegoat, a name that’s become a source for bad luck, in order to explain the things that are beyond everyone’s control.